Search This Blog

Tuesday, November 1, 2016

If Ben Franklin Could Vote

The Statue of Benjamin Franklin at Lincoln Park in Chicago, Ill.

You've got to hand it to Pennsylvania voters. They must be among the most patriotic Americans. After all, as the redoubtable Robert Knight recently revealed, hundreds of voters over 100 have been casting ballots, apparently for years.

One was reportedly born on August 7, 1853, making him a very young 163. He voted in both 2008 and 2012. Hopefully he won't miss the 2016 election. It's great to see that sort of commitment to our democracy!

Even more impressive, hundreds of voters were listed with birthdates of 1800. To be a double centenarian, but still able to go to the polls. That is real democracy in action.

Sadly missing from the list of voters, however, is Benjamin Franklin, polymath, raconteur, scientist and founder. He died in 1790, so even in Philadelphia he hasn't been able to vote. At least that we know of. Wherever he's at, he probably has some sharp opinions about American politics today.

Indeed, he was concerned about the future of the new nation even then. On leaving the Constitutional Convention he was accosted by a lady who asked what kind of government the delegates had created. Franklin responded, "A republic, if you can keep it."

He could not have been more prescient.

Although we look back on the founding through a rosy lens, America's survival was not guaranteed. The colonists shared the continent with multiple Indian tribes, and only after decades of bloody combat did the European settlers finally conquer the entire territory which now makes up continental America.

France and Spain, military allies of the rebellious colonies, did not want to see a strong republican government take root. Within a couple decades Napoleonic France ended up attacking American commerce. Britain remained hostile, failed to withdraw military garrisons as promised, and soon was at war with the U.S. again.

However, the most serious challenge was domestic. Americans' commitment to their states hindered creation of a national government capable of the one function of national governments everywhere: defending against outside threats in what remained a very dangerous world. Unanimity was rarely reached, bills went unpaid, violent unrest challenged domestic authorities, foreign empires treated the U.S. with disdain. Americans wanted liberty, but failed to take the steps necessary to protect it.

Hence the Constitutional Convention. In school most of us learned about the "Miracle in Philadelphia" which prompted Franklin's remark.

But most textbooks stop there and never consider whether we fulfilled his important charge to future generations. In this most frustrating of election years -- in which some approaching Franklin's generation apparently are still voting! -- it behooves us to ask: Can we keep our republic?

Tragically, we are dangerously close to losing it. Indeed, we might be one election away from the end of America as we know it.

First, the Constitution itself no longer has much to do with governing America. Politicians and bureaucrats pay little attention to it. Judges rewrite it. The rule of law has become the rule of the judiciary.

Second, elections no longer guarantee citizens a free and fair ballot. Districts are gerrymandered, votes are bought with public spending, and the electoral process itself is corrupted. Voter rolls are filled with the dead, judges forbid electoral safeguards, non-citizens cast ballots.

Third, education has been corrupted and degraded by government schools. Rather than learn how to be a good citizens, students are lucky if they get the basics of reading and writing. Too many people don't understand their responsibilities as citizens.

Fourth, the Founders' vision of a limited government based on individual liberty has been swept aside by Leviathan. America might not yet have arrived at Bernie Sanders' socialist utopia, but the U.S. is racing in that direction as Washington continues to take over more of people's lives.

Fifth, the original constitutional barriers to a unitary government chosen by a national majority continue to fall. State sovereignty has been dramatically eroded, senators are now elected directly, and Washington interferes with state election law. There also is a concerted campaign to eliminate the Electoral College, which would turn presidential races into a simple popularity contest, something the Founders sought to guard against.

Finally, every step down this road moves closer to the moment of no return. It becomes increasingly difficult to appeal to a higher good as more people treat the national government as a vehicle for self-enrichment.

We must fight to keep our republic.

Election fraud is serious. But it's not as destructive as the sacrifice of America's republican heritage. Ben Franklin hoped the new republic would endure, but recognized the challenges to come. Americans must act now to remain worthy stewards of self-government.

Ken Blackwell is the former Secretary State of Ohio. He a Senior Fellow at the American Civil Rights Union and the Family Research Council.


Read More Here

US officials see no link between Trump and Russia: report

US officials see no link between Trump and Russia: report
By Lisa Hagen - 10-31-16 21:52 PM EDT

Amid multiple reports drawing different connections between Donald Trump's campaign and Russia Monday night, The New York Times reported that FBI officials' investigations of the GOP presidential nominee have yet to confirm any ties.

FBI officials said their investigations have yet to find a connection between the GOP presidential nominee and Russia.

The bureau has been investigating the Russian government's role in the U.S. presidential election. But the FBI believes that the country was likely trying to disrupt the overall race and not trying boost Trump's chance of getting elected.

The Monday night report comes after CNBC reported earlier in the day that FBI Director James Comey argued against accusing Russia of interfering in the election due to the timing and because he did not want the accusation against Russia to come from his agency.

And Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) alleged earlier in the day that the FBI has "explosive information" about a connection, suggesting federal investigators have "explosive information about close ties and coordination between Donald Trump, his top advisors and the Russian government" and must make it public.

Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton and critics have criticized Trump for praising Russian President Vladimir Putin. But Trump has pushed back, saying he has "nothing to do" with Russia and doesn't know Putin.

The conclusions also come amid a report from Slate that an unnamed computer scientist found a connection between a Trump organization server and two servers registered to a Moscow bank.

The FBI is also reportedly looking into former Trump campaign manager Paul Manafort's foreign business and political dealings, according to NBC.

FBI officials declined to comment for the Times story, but intelligence officials have said in interviews over the past several weeks that apparent connections between Trump aides and Moscow motivated them to open a larger investigation.

So far, no evidence that has surfaced that Trump has any links to Russia.

National poll: Trump now leads Clinton by 1 point

National poll: Trump now leads Clinton by 1 point
By Mark Hensch - 11-01-16 07:12 AM EDT

Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump has overtaken Democratic rival Hillary Clinton for the first time since May in the ABC News/Washington Post tracking poll.

Trump has a 1-point lead over the former secretary of State, 46 to 45 percent, as of Tuesday morning.

Libertarian nominee Gary Johnson registers at a new low of 3 percent, while Green Party nominee Jill Stein rounds out the field with 2 percent.

Fifty-three percent of likely voters have "strong enthusiasm" for Trump, according to the poll, while 45 percent feel the same about Clinton.

Clinton led Trump by 1 point, 46 percent to 45 percent, in the same poll over the weekend. She held a 12-point lead, 50 to 38 percent, in the poll just more than one week ago.

Voters voiced more enthusiasm for Clinton's campaign, with 52 percent saying they had "strong enthusiasm" for her and 49 percent stating the same of Trump.

The Washington Post/ABC News conducted its latest poll of 1,128 likely voters via cellphone and landline telephone interviews from Oct. 27 to 30. It has a margin of error of 3 percentage points.

Clinton leads Trump by about 2 points nationwide, according to the latest RealClearPolitics average of surveys.

Recent polling shows a tightening race between Clinton and Trump at both the national and state levels just one week from Election Day.

Clinton is under fire following a weekend of negative headlines over a new FBI probe into emails from the private server she used while secretary of State.

FBI Director James Comey told lawmakers in a letter last Friday that the bureau had found fresh emails that may prove "pertinent" to its investigation of Clinton's emails.

The new emails were discovered during an unrelated probe of former Rep. Anthony Weiner (D-N.Y.), the estranged husband of longtime Clinton aide Huma Abedin.

This report was updated at 7:36 a.m.

Holocaust Survivor: UN’s Jewish ‘Temple Denial Is Worse Than Holocaust Denial’

On Wednesday, UNESCO passed by secret ballot a second resolution attempting to erase any Jewish or Christian connection to Jerusalem’s holy sites, referring to them solely by their Arabic names, even though the first such resolution had sparked outrage among world leaders. Israel’s government had responded by cutting ties with UNESCO. Israeli sentiment ranged from tragedy to absurdity.

Prominent Israeli archeologist Gabriel Barkay suggested that UNESCO’s denial of the Jewish Temple is worse than Holocaust denial. Ofer Zalzberg, “Israel/Palestine analyst” for International Crisis Group, argued the mainstream media has missed the crux of the issue by focusing on terms rather than substance.

Barkay was born in Hungary in 1944, the same year German troops invaded and occupied his country. After immigrating to Israel and becoming a prominent archeologist, he established and co-directed the Temple Mount Sifting Project dedicated to recovering archeological artifacts from Temple Mount dirt that the Jerusalem Islamic Waqf bulldozed and discarded in 1999. Barkay says the UNESCO resolution’s temple denial is even worse than Holocaust denial.

This Isn’t Just Rhetoric

First of all, notes Barkay, Temple deniers, like Holocaust deniers, completely ignore historical and archeological fact. But whereas victims, perpetrators, and documents from the Holocaust still exist, as well as the actual concentration camp sites, the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem, whose artifacts date back thousands of years, is easier to deny.

Second, undermining the Jewish connection to Jerusalem also undermines the entire basis for Christianity as well as Islamic literary references to Jerusalem as Bait al Maqdis, translated from the Hebrew Beit HaMikdash (The Holy Temple) and referring to the First Temple.

Last and most importantly, Barkay believes the request for Waqf control over Jerusalem’s holy sites is “part of a general attitude” promoting destruction of non-Muslim artifacts, citing previous destruction of Temple Mount artifacts and the Islamic State’s destruction of ancient religious heritage sites in Iraq, Syria, and Libya.

He also cited the Waqf’s hypocrisy of opposing archeological digs on the Temple Mount, which represents one-sixth of the Old City, while asking for proof of Jewish connection to the Temple Mount, or what Arabs call the Haram al-Sharif. Barkay denounces the UNESCO vote as “a deplorable decision that ignores historical and archeological fact. It is a disgrace to anybody who thinks himself to be a civilized person.”

Blame the Bureaucrats

Rabbi Shmuel Rabinowitz, rabbi of the Western Wall and Holy Sites in Israel, stated flatly that after this decision, UNESCO has forfeited its right to exist. “The holiness of the Temple Mount and the Western Wall for the Jewish people … does not need anyone’s approval. It is ridiculous to deny the [archeological] discoveries that are occurring all the time.”

International Crisis Group’s Ofer Zalzberg had a different take on the UNESCO resolution, criticizing the media’s focus on the terminology about holy sites over the substance of the decision. He explained that Jordanian- and Palestinian-drafted resolutions normally use Arabic terms, so it’s simply part of UNESCO’s bureaucratic routine. “Everything that created the controversy is a long-standing norm in this organization,” said Zalzberg. “There has not been any government decision to implement it on Jordanian, Palestinian, or Israeli sides. Everyone has been surprised that it became such a big issue.”

Zalzberg did note the resolution’s bias insofar as it “does not point to one infraction or self-criticism on the Jordanian-Palestinian side. Only at Israel as the so-called occupying power.” After vilifying Israel, the document requests a change in the way holy sites are managed.

Namely, it requests a return to pre-intifada management in which both parties coordinate on security and access, worship, and protecting the antiquities. According to Zalzberg, this could work, as there was “very little violence at the site from 1967-1996” until the Waqf halted all coordination with Israel after Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu opened the northern tunnels.

Paradoxically, it was then 1996 when the Waqf rejected Israel’s call to return to coordination—the very objective UNESCO sought in its resolution this week. But because of the offensive terminology, the Jordanian-Palestinian duo shot themselves in the foot. It’s yet another absurdity in the UNESCO resolution.


Read More Here

Obamacare Supporters Refuse To Enroll In Obamacare Because It’s Garbage

Today, the beginning of Obamacare’s fourth open enrollment period, will see Obama administration officials and liberal advocates engaging in the usual publicity blitz. They’ll tell Americans how much money they can save, how affordable plans are—don’t believe the hype about premium increases, they claim—and the benefits of having health coverage.

All of this can be rebutted by one simple rejoinder: If these exchange plans are so good, why haven’t you purchased one?

It’s a question I’ve asked several Obamacare advocates, because, while they talk about Obamacare, I actually have to live it. Because Washington DC abolished its private insurance market, I as a small business owner have to buy a plan on the federal exchange. For 2017, new plan requirements by the DC exchange—insurers now have to offer eight “standardized” plans—coupled with the difficult business environment meant that my insurer, CareFirst Blue Cross, cancelled its health savings account plan.

As a result, I and 6,980 other HSA plan participants received cancellation notices in September. As you can see from the notice, the “substitute” plan I was offered has a premium of $296.40—that’s a 20.2 percent increase, for those of you keeping score at home—and a 25 percent increase in my deductible, from $1,600 to $2,000.

jacobs3

The day before I received official confirmation of my plan’s cancellation, I attended a briefing on insurance exchanges. I pointed out that, to most people in Washington DC, Obamacare was an abstract idea. Policy-makers at think-tanks, lobbying firms, or in government have high-paying jobs that come with employer-based health coverage, so they really don’t have to worry about whether the exchanges succeed or fail.

I asked the panelists point-blank: You’re speaking about the state of Obamacare’s exchanges, but do you yourself receive coverage through them?

As I had suspected, most admitted they do not. Sabrina Corlette, a Georgetown University researcher, replied that she was a “spoiled academic” who received coverage through her employer. Ironically enough, Corlette’s presentation for the briefing included a slide noting that the exchanges needed to “boost enrollment.” But when asked whether she would enroll in an exchange plan—thereby boosting enrollment—she said she would not. This brings to mind St. Augustine’s famous phrase, “Grant me chastity and continence—but not yet.”

Elites Won’t Join Obamacare’s Ghettoes

One reason why Corlette, and other “spoiled academics” like her, won’t give up their existing coverage is simple: Compared to employer-based insurance, exchange plans—and this is a technical term—suck.

Thanks to Obamacare’s ability to make insurance competition disappear, nearly one in five Americans (19 percent) will have the “choice” of only one insurer on their exchange in 2017. Obamacare’s benefit mandates have forced insurers to narrow networks—three-quarters of all 2017 exchange offerings include no out-of-network coverage—and raise deductibles so high as to render insurance “all but useless” for many.

As I have previously written, Obamacare’s insurance marketplaces could be more accurately described as ghettoes, not exchanges. The median income among all healthcare.gov enrollees is 165 percent of the poverty level, or about $40,000 for a family of four, so enrollees are predominantly low-income, besides sicker than those on the average employer plan. The combination of narrow networks and tightly managed care has zero appeal to the average person with an employer plan—which explains why the liberal elites promoting Obamacare won’t actually enroll themselves.

‘I Do Try to Think about Them’

At the September briefing, Corlette claimed Obamacare was an attempt to “lift the standards for individual market products” to make them more like employer plans—just not enough for her to enroll. (As someone actually on the exchanges, I can attest to a lot of “lift” for my premiums and deductibles; standards and network access, perhaps not as much.)

She then justified her non-participation in the exchanges by claiming that “when I look at these issues, I do try to think about them. You know, if I were an expecting mother who needs prenatal care…what kind of health insurance would I want?”

All of this sounds as empathetic as thinking about and waving at people in a rowboat from the creature comforts of one’s private yacht. Her condescending tone presupposes that, while exchange plans might not totally replicate employer coverage, they’ll pass muster for “them”—not actually good enough for the elites themselves, mind you, but good enough for the unwashed masses who will purchase the plans.

If one wants to explain the reasons for the rise of Donald Trump, one could start with a group of elites who think they can determine what others want, even while deliberately segregating themselves from the effects of the policies they created.

As the saying goes, actions speak louder than words. If advocates of Obamacare actually believed the law was providing insurance comparable to employer plans, they would switch to exchange coverage. That they are not speaks to the law’s fundamental problem: Liberal elites can sell the benefits of Obamacare all they want, but when it comes time to put one’s money where one’s mouth is, the American people aren’t buying—and neither are the liberals.


Read More Here

Wikileaks Reveals Google's "Strategic Plan" To Help Democrats Win The Election, Track Voters

Among the latest set of Podesta releases, was the following email sent on April 15, 2014 by Google's Eric Schmidt titled "Notes for a 2016 Democratic Campaign" in which the Google/Alphabet Chairman tells Cheryl Mills that "I have put together my thoughts on the campaign ideas and I have scheduled some meetings in the next few weeks for veterans of the campaign to tell me how to make these ideas better.  This is simply a draft but do let me know if this is a helpful process for you all."

 

While there are numerous curious nuances in the plan, presented below in its entirety, the one section that caught our - and Wikileaks' attention - is the following which implicitly suggests Google planned the creation of a voter tracking database, using smart phones:

Key is the development of a single record for a voter that aggregates all that is known about them.  In 2016 smart phones will be used to identify, meet, and update profiles on the voter.  A dynamic volunteer can easily speak with a voter and, with their email or other digital handle, get the voter videos and other answers to areas they care about (“the benefits of ACA to you” etc.)

As a reminder, two days ago it was revealed that just days prior to the April 15, 2014 email, Schmidt had sent another email in which he expressed his eagerness to "fund" the campaign efforts and wants to be a "head outside advisor." In the email from John Podesta to Robby Mook we learned that:

I met with Eric Schmidt tonight. As David reported, he's ready to fund, advise recruit talent, etc. He was more deferential on structure than I expected. Wasn't pushing to run through one of his existing firms. Clearly wants to be head outside advisor, but didn't seem like he wanted to push others out. Clearly wants to get going. He's still in DC tomorrow and would like to meet with you if you are in DC in the afternoon. I think it's worth doing. You around? If you are, and want to meet with him, maybe the four of us can get on t

Another email from February 2015 suggested that the Google Chairman remained active in its collaboration with the Clinton campaign: John Podesta wrote that Eric Schmidt met with HR "about the business he proposes to do with the campaign. He says he's met with HRC" and adds that "FYI. They are donating the Google plane for the Africa trip"

The remainder of Schmidt's proposed plan, presented in its entirety below, is just as troubling. 

Notes for a 2016 Democratic Campaign
Eric Schmidt
April 2014

DRAFT DRAFT DRAFT DRAFT

Here are some comments and observations based on what we saw in the 2012 campaign.  If we get started soon, we will be in a very strong position to execute well for 2016.

1. Size, Structure and Timing

Lets assume a total budget of about $1.5Billion, with more than 5000 paid employees and million(s) of volunteers.  The entire startup ceases operation four days after November 8, 2016.  The structure includes a Chairman or Chairwoman who is the external face of the campaign and a President who is the executive in charge of objectives, measurements, systems and building and managing the organization.

Every day matters as our end date does not change.  An official campaign right after midterm elections and a preparatory team assembled now is best.

2. Location

The campaign headquarters will have about a thousand people, mostly young and hardworking and enthusiastic.  Its important to have a very large hiring pool (such as Chicago or NYC) from which to choose enthusiastic, smart and low paid permanent employees.  DC is a poor choice as its full of distractions and interruptions.  Moving the location from DC elsewhere guarantees visitors have taken the time to travel and to help.

The key is a large population of talented people who are dying to work for you.  Any outer borough of NYC, Philadelphia, Atlanta, Boston are all good examples of a large, blue state city to base in.

Employees will relocate to participate in the campaign, and will find low cost temporary housing or live with campaign supporters on a donated basis.  This worked well in Chicago and can work elsewhere.

The computers will be in the cloud and most likely on Amazon Web services (AWS).  All the campaign needs are portable computers, tablets and smart phones along with credit card readers.

3. The pieces of a Campaign

a) The Field

Its important to have strong field leadership, with autonomy and empowerment.  Operations talent needs to build the offices, set up the systems, hire the people, and administer what is about 5000 people.  Initial modeling will show heavy hiring in the key battleground states.  There is plenty of time to set these functions up and build the human systems.  The field is about organizing people, voter contact, and get out the vote programs.

For organizing tools, build a simple way to link people and activities as a workflow and let the field manage the system, all cloud based.  Build a simple organizing tool with a functioning back-end.  Avoid deep integration as the benefits are not worth it.  Build on the cloud.  Organizing is really about sharing and linking people, and this tool would measure and track all of it.

There are many other crucial early investments needed in the field: determining the precise list of battleground states, doing early polling to confirm initial biases, and maintaining and extending voter protection programs at the state level.

b) The Voter

Key is the development of a single record for a voter that aggregates all that is known about them.  In 2016 smart phones will be used to identify, meet, and update profiles on the voter.  A dynamic volunteer can easily speak with a voter and, with their email or other digital handle, get the voter videos and other answers to areas they care about (“the benefits of ACA to you” etc.)

The scenario includes a volunteer on a walk list, encountering a potential voter, updating the records real time and deepening contact with the voter and the information we have to offer.

c) Digital

A large group of campaign employees will use digital marketing methods to connect to voters, to offer information, to use social networks to spread good news, and to raise money.  Partners like Blue State Digital will do much of the fund raising.  A key point is to convert BSD and other partners to pure cloud service offerings to handle the expected crush and load.

d) Media (paid), (earned) and (social), and polling

New tools should be developed to measure reach and impact of paid, earned and social media.  The impact of press coverage should be measurable in reach and impact, and TV effectiveness measured by attention and other surveys.  

Build tools that measure the rate and spread of stories and rumors, and model how it works and who has the biggest impact.  Tools can tell us about the origin of stories and the impact of any venue, person or theme.  Connect polling into this in some way.  

Find a way to do polling online and not on phones.

e) Analytics and data science and modeling, polling and resource optimization tools

For each voter, a score is computed ranking probability of the right vote.  Analytics can model demographics, social factors and many other attributes of the needed voters.  Modeling will tell us what who we need to turn out and why, and studies of effectiveness will let us know what approaches work well.    Machine intelligence across the data should identify the most important factors for turnout, and preference.

It should be possible to link the voter records in Van with upcoming databases from companies like Comcast and others for media measurement purposes.

The analytics tools can be built in house or partnered with a set of vendors.

f) Core engineering, voter database and contact with voters online

The database of voters (NGP Van) is a fine starting point for voter records and is maintained by the vendor (and needs to be converted to the cloud).  The code developed for 2012 (Narwahl etc.) is unlikely to be used, and replaced by a model where the vendor data is kept in the Van database and intermediate databases are arranged with additional information for a voter.

Quite a bit of software is to be developed to match digital identities with the actual voter file with high confidence.  The key unit of the campaign is a “voter”, and each and every record is viewable and updatable by volunteers in search of more accurate information.

In the case where we can’t identify the specific human, we can still have a partial digital voter id, for a person or “probable-person” with attributes that we can identify and use to target.  As they respond we can eventually match to a registered voter in the main file.  This digital key is eventually matched to a real person.

The Rules

Its important that all the player in the campaign work at cost and there be no special interests in the financing structure.  This means that all vendors work at cost and there is a separate auditing function to ensure no one is profiting unfairly from the campaign.  All investments and conflicts of interest would have to be publicly disclosed.  The rules of the audit should include caps on individual salaries and no investor profits from the campaign function.  (For example, this rule would apply to me.)

The KEY things

a) early build of an integrated development team and recognition that this is an entire system that has to be managed as such
b) decisions to exclusively use cloud solutions for scalability, and choice of vendors and any software from 2012 that will be reused.
c) the role of the smart phone in the hands of a volunteer.  The smart phone manages the process, updates the database, informs the citizen, and allows fundraising and recruitment of volunteers (on android and iphone).
d) early and continued focus of qualifying fundraising dollars to build the field, and build all the tools.  Outside money will be plentiful and perfect for TV use.  A smart media mix tool tells all we need to know about media placement, TV versus other media and digital media.


Read More Here

Podesta Part 25: Wikileaks Releases Another 2,460 Emails, Total Is Now 41,969

It is now exactly one week until the election, and what until recently seemed impossible, is suddenly all too real: the latest ABC/WaPo shows that Trump has a one point lead over Hillary, his first since May, and much of its thanks to the ongoing Wikileaks release of highly damaging Podesta emails. So, in the final stretch of the presidential race which has just a few days left, Wikileaks continues its ongoing broadside attack against the Clinton campaign with the relentless Podesta dump, by unveiling another 2,458 emails in the latest, Part 25 of its Podesta release, bringing the total emails released so far to exactly 41,969.

The release comes one day after Wikileaks warned that it was launching its "Phase 3" of election coverage this week, raising questions what else - if anything - Julian Assange has up his sleeve. 

As usual we are parsing through the latest release and will bring readers the more notable emails.


Read More Here